In the land of rec.aquaria.marine.reefs, the word of the Lord came
to Joel and verily he spoke saying:
> For a 40 gallon tank, how much should you spend? What would YOU
> get?
I have found that the average price for a decent skimmer is between
$200 and $350. I have a 29 gallon tank running a somewhat effective
custom made skimmer that is better by far that anything I have seen
the prizm do firsthand but seconded by any, and every real (defined
as an in-sump or inline skimmer rated to be effective at or above 100
gallons) skimmer by far I bought it locally for $150 and it is about
the equivilent of the CPR BakPak.
I have heard that the remora series of hang on skimmers, and the CPR
BakPak skimmers are good. Unfortunately I can not speak from
experience having never had a 40 gallon tank (I've had a 3 gallon
going on two years 5.5 gallon sold it after 1.5 years, 10 gallon that
I upgraded to 29 gallon after 1.5 years, 29 gallon just over three
years, and am setting up a 75 gallon) and as such can only parrot
what I have heard. You should definetly consider a sump for a tank
that size. It will increase your water valume and thus allow you to
more easily recover from mistakes and allow for the tank to handle a
larger bioload. It will also drasticly improve the astethics of your
tank by hiding the heater, thermomiter, skimmer, filter intakes if
applicable etc. All you need to set one up is a small rubbermaid
container full of saltwater, an overflow box of some kind (check ebay
for a deal on one) and a decent pump to return water to the tank.
Good luck!

Signature
-John
Because it makes things difficult to understand.
Why shouldn't I top post?
Marc Levenson - 28 Feb 2004 05:20 GMT
Definitely put a Aqua C Remora on that tank. If you *think you might upgrade*
then get a Remora Pro.
Buying a used one will save money. The only part that can break is the pump
itself, assuming the acrylic unit has not been dropped / cracked / or smashed.
I've bought two used ones and am very happy.
Marc
> > For a 40 gallon tank, how much should you spend? What would YOU
> > get?
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
> for a deal on one) and a decent pump to return water to the tank.
> Good luck!
--
Personal Page: http://www.sparklingfloorservice.com/oanda/index.html
Business Page: http://www.sparklingfloorservice.com
Marine Hobbyist: http://www.melevsreef.com