Thanks for the information. How does this compare to radiation
treatment in terms of expense; is the primary expense in the cost
of the drug or the anesthesia? In this case it would be injected
directly into the tumor. By being "comfortable with" what do you mean?
> Thanks for the information. How does this compare to radiation
> treatment in terms of expense;
I'd guess carboplatin treatment is less expensive than full-course
radiation therapy, although it may be more expensive than palliative
radiation therapy. Understand, though, that the choice isn't usually
carbo vs. radiation. I don't know exactly what cancer you're asking
about, but depending on the tumor, the choices for treatment will vary.
> is the primary expense in the cost
> of the drug or the anesthesia?
There is no anesthesia costs with carboplatin use. The drug is very
expensive.
> In this case it would be injected
> directly into the tumor. By being "comfortable with" what do you mean?
>
Carboplatin isn't injected into tumor. Now, if you're talking about
carboplatin *beads*, then that's a completely different ball game, so
ignore all I've said in this thread. These are little dissolving beads
that are coated with carboplatin so that the drug is slowly released
into the local area of a tumor. It's used only in cases of soft tissue
sarcomas, as far as I know. It's a very new treatment for animals, so I
can't tell you how that treatment compares to radiation therapy
post-operatively. There are no general practitioners using these beads.
Our local oncologist is still trying to figure out the best way to get
them into tumors for those pets not undergoing surgery, where they can
be placed where they want to put them.
Wendy, I really think you should be talking to your primary care
veterinarian or your pet's oncologist about these specifics. I feel that
I may just be confusing the matter because I don't have all the
information and you're still learning what needs to be done for your pup.
Sandy, DVM
>
>>
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
>>
>>
WendyS817 - 22 Sep 2008 02:34 GMT
>> Thanks for the information. How does this compare to radiation
>> treatment in terms of expense;
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
> to get them into tumors for those pets not undergoing surgery, where
> they can be placed where they want to put them.
No I am talking about a treatment that was used since the early 90's,
using injections of sesame seed oil/carboplatin injected, in this case,
into a squamous cell carcinoma tumor of the nose of cats. See:
Intratumoral administration of carboplatin for treatment of squamous
cell carcinomas of the nasal plane in cats. AJVR, v57, No. 2, Feb. 1996.
It requires anesthesia for the injections, which means that this
treatment may be as expensive or more so than radiation. I was just
wondering if the average vet could do this procedure. Has a fairly high
percentage response rate. We have alot of vets here who say they are
full service, but they are afraid to do much beyond the simple stuff.
> Wendy, I really think you should be talking to your primary care
> veterinarian or your pet's oncologist about these specifics. I feel
> that I may just be confusing the matter because I don't have all the
> information and you're still learning what needs to be done for your
> pup.
not a pup, a cat.
> Sandy, DVM
>>
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
>>
>>
Sandy, DVM - 23 Sep 2008 03:18 GMT
Interesting abstract from 1996. I'm not saying I'm an expert, but I
haven't heard of any oncologists using this technique, Wendy. Was this
treatment suggested to you an an option for your kitty? I would imagine
it's less expensive than radiation therapy, but I can't compare survival
rates or disease free intervals.
Best of luck with a difficult disease.
Sandy, DVM
> No I am talking about a treatment that was used since the early 90's,
> using injections of sesame seed oil/carboplatin injected, in this case,
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> percentage response rate. We have alot of vets here who say they are
> full service, but they are afraid to do much beyond the simple stuff.